Anti-Beef Debate

Anti-Beef Debate

University debate: “Beef is the most wasteful food on earth.”

Vegan: “It takes 25 kilos of feed to make one kilo of beef. Any other machine that lost 96% of what went into it would be scrapped.”

Farmer: “25 kilos of what?”

Vegan: “Feed.”

Farmer: “Grass. How much of it can you eat?”

Vegan: “None. That isn’t the point.”

Farmer: “It’s the whole sum. A gold mine shifts a tonne of rock for five grams of gold. Nobody stands at the gate complaining about the waste of rock.”

Vegan: “Rock isn’t food. That land could feed people directly.”

Farmer: “Two thirds of Britain’s farmland is grass. Most of it is too steep, too wet or too thin to be anything else. You’re welcome to try it with a spoon.”

Vegan: “They’re fattened on grain at the end.”

Farmer: “Mine finish on silage and what the brewery throws out. The barley made your pint first.”

Vegan: “Even so, 25 to one is indefensible.”

Farmer: “A wheat plant is roots, stalk, chaff and grain. You eat the grain. That’s about half of it wasted before the miller starts. I don’t see a motion about bread.”

Moderator: “Closing lines, please.”

Vegan: “A hungry world can’t afford a food that takes 25 in to get one out.”

Farmer: “25 kilos of something you can’t eat, off land you can’t plough, for one kilo of the best food there is. I’d call that the only free lunch in farming.”